About this role
About the job
Join SmartFinancial
SmartFinancial is a leading insurance marketplace connecting millions of shoppers with our network of insurance partners. Our mission is to help insurance agencies grow through innovative technology and meaningful consumer connections.
We’re looking for a hands-on Team Lead I to support our Tampa contact center. In this role, you will lead an assigned team of agents who screen consumer prospects and transfer qualified shoppers to insurance carriers and agency partners. You’ll stay close to daily performance, provide practical coaching, and hold agents accountable while creating an environment where they can succeed.
What You’ll Do
- Lead the daily activities of your assigned team in a fast-paced contact center handling outbound and inbound calls.
- Manage team performance against established production, conversion, quality, and productivity targets in support of company revenue goals.
- Monitor agent performance throughout the day, identify gaps, and take timely action to address them.
- Conduct call reviews, live listening, and side-by-side observations to reinforce effective call handling, required scripting, accurate information collection, and transfer procedures.
- Deliver clear, actionable coaching, document expectations, and follow up to measure improvement.
- Monitor attendance, schedule adherence, after-call work, breaks, and productive time; address concerns consistently under company policy.
- Review performance reports and maintain accurate coaching, attendance, and corrective action documentation.
- Address routine agent questions and performance concerns, and escalate issues that require additional leadership or People Operations support.
- Partner with leadership and People Operations on employee concerns, policy issues, and corrective action.
- Reinforce compliance with applicable legal requirements, departmental policies, and carrier-specific instructions.
- Support new agents as they transition from training to their assigned team, and provide ongoing development to existing agents.
- Participate in quality calibrations and share recurring call-handling issues, training needs, and process improvement opportunities with leadership.
- Promote employee engagement through recognition, incentives, and team activities.
- Communicate team results, staffing concerns, and operational issues to leadership, including leaders based outside Tampa.
- Assist with inbound and outbound calls as needed.
- Perform other duties as assigned.
Requirements
- What We’re Looking For
- A hands-on leader who sets clear expectations and follows through.
- The ability to identify performance gaps, explain what needs to change, and coach agents toward improvement.
- Strong organizational skills and the ability to prioritize competing needs in a fast-paced environment.
- Comfortable reviewing reports and using performance data to guide daily decisions.
- Clear verbal and written communication skills.
- An approachable, professional manner and the ability to handle difficult conversations fairly and consistently.
- Sound judgment when applying policies, documenting concerns, and determining when to escalate an issue.
- The ability to learn and use dialer platforms, reporting tools, and other business applications.
Qualifications
- Three or more years of team management experience required.
- Five or more years of customer service and/or sales experience required.
- Experience in outbound telemarketing or a high-volume contact center preferred.
- Experience managing on-site employees.
- Bachelor’s degree preferred; an equivalent combination of education and relevant experience will also be considered.
Benefits
What We Offer
- Health insurance and a 401(k) plan with company match.
- Employee referral bonuses and daily and weekly cash giveaways.
- Paid product and inside sales training.
- Career growth opportunities, with a focus on promoting from within.
- An engaged workplace with employee recognition, team activities, and company events.
Why SmartFinancial?
Our people are a big part of what makes SmartFinancial a great place to work. From active Slack channels to team celebrations and company events, we create opportunities to connect, recognize accomplishments, and enjoy the work we do together. You’ll also get to know Penny, our pink pig mascot—and the company swag that comes with her.
Ready to help agents perform, develop, and succeed? Apply to join our Tampa team.
SmartFinancial is an equal opportunity employer. We celebrate diversity and are committed to creating an inclusive environment for all employees.
About the company
SmartFinancial Insurance More jobs Making insurance shopping process easier and more efficient 51-200 Employees
Cleveland
51-200
Insurance
Health and Insurance
Insurance Companies
Top 5% of responders
SmartFinancial Insurance is in the top 5% of companies in terms of response time to applications
Responds within a few days
Based on past data, SmartFinancial Insurance usually responds to incoming applications within a few days
B2C
+1
Top 5% of responders
SmartFinancial Insurance is in the top 5% of companies in terms of response time to applications
Responds within a few days
Based on past data, SmartFinancial Insurance usually responds to incoming applications within a few days
B2C
+1
Save
Apply Now
About the company
SmartFinancial Insurance More jobs Making insurance shopping process easier and more efficient51-200 Employees
Cleveland
51-200
Insurance
Health and Insurance
Insurance Companies
Growth Stage
Expanding market presence
Employees joined from
CarParts
University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee
Rite Aid
Advanced Inflight Alliance
Iksha Labs Private Limited
American Credit Acceptance
Learn more about SmartFinancial Insurance
Founders
Lev Barinskiy Founder
Columbus
View the team
More jobs at SmartFinancial Insurance
- Sales ManagerNewport Beach→
- Senior Full Stack Ruby on Rails EngineerNewport Beach · $150k – $170k→
- Senior Enterprise Sales Leader (Commercial Insurance)Newport Beach · $200k – $200k→
View all jobs at SmartFinancial Insurance
Similar Jobs